Tristan, Jacob and Joshua talk Iron Viz 2017
Dramatic! Exciting! Nerve-wracking! Those are the words I've heard to describe this year's Iron Viz competition. But what was it like to be a contestant, up on stage for the entire Tableau community to see? Tristan Guillevin, Jacob Olsufka and Joshua Milligan share their thoughts about preparing for and competing in this year's big tent event.
How did you prepare for the competition?
Jacob: It took me a couple of days of exploring the data to pick out the story I wanted, after I had settled on my dashboard it was a lot of practice, practice, practice. I prepped for distractions by building my viz with episodes of The Office on in front of me. The roughly 20-minute episodes made this perfect! For one of my last practice rounds I kicked the distractions up a few notches and had loud metal music playing. (Apologies to my neighbors!)
Joshua: I reviewed Storytelling with Data by Cole Nussbaumer Knaflic and also the Big Book of Dashboards. I also looked at previous Iron Viz dashboards to see what stories the contestants had told. Once I received the official data set, I spent some time exploring it and pretty quickly found a story I wanted to tell. I arrived in Vegas with the outline of a dashboard and then spent time with my sous-vizzer, David Freifeld, who had some great suggestions and really helped me improve the finished product!
Tristan: After winning the IronViz Safari feeder, I started to participate in MakeoverMonday (by Eva Murray and Andy Kriebel). It helped me build a dashboard and a story with new data every week, and sometimes data that I found not interesting. Once I received the Iron Viz dataset, my main goal was to find a story and build a dashboard around it. I had some key things in my mind as I built it: make the story interesting and make sure the public wants to use it. Jade Le Van, my sous-vizzer, helped me during that process with great advice. In Las Vegas, she also helped me to repeat the complete process of creation and speech. She tried to distract me by speaking, playing music or even putting her smartphone flash on my face so I will feel “in condition!”
What was your first thought when you received the dataset?
Jacob: I love working with big data sets, and am particularly attracted to demographic, US Census type data, so I was very excited to be able to work with Zillow’s data. I’ve been experimenting with implementing Pages into data storytelling to better engage the audience for a while, so I knew I wanted to try to work that into my presentation somehow. Once I saw how the distribution chart completely swung from one side to the other during the crash, I knew that I had found my story, and the map and city comparison came together off of that.
Joshua: The structure of the data was the first thing that struck me as each measure and each geographic level of detail was a subset of data, so there wasn’t a really well-defined level of detail for the entire data set. The other thing that struck me was the need to understand the subject matter. I didn’t really know what the Zillow Home Value Index was or how it could be used. But as I explored the data, I realized that the structure of the data actually made some analysis easier. And as I began to dig into the stories in the data, I realized how rich the data was and how valuable the index could be in uncovering insights in the housing market.
Tristan: “Je suis foutu,” meaning “I’m screwed” in English. How I, a young French, could compete against two Americans with a completely US-centered dataset about home values. But I love data and I love challenges. So I started to use my condition as a force and I built I dashboard with things I could understand, simple and engaging. A dashboard that even I could enjoy using.
Some tricks to share to finish a complete dashboard in 20 minutes?
Jacob: Being part of IronViz made me grasp just how fast 20 minutes can go by, but at the same time realized that quite a bit can be accomplished in Tableau in only 20 minutes. I had almost every click and order of operations down, but I used several tricks to help make the build as efficient as possible. First off, I used the Pause Auto Updates button in Tableau so that my map only had to render once it was on the dashboard and all of the formatting and details were in place. Because I used shapefiles for the MSA areas, this took a few minutes to load in Tableau, but ended up being worth it so that we could see how the housing market shifted at a more detailed and market specific level. I took advantage of duplicating sheets to copy formatting, and used the dashboarding features of formatting all worksheet titles at once to save time.
Joshua: I’ve been working on speed ever since entering Tableau’s 3-minute win contest in 2013! And the ability to create something fast is one of the things I love about Tableau – it truly is the speed of thought. There are definitely some tricks to working fast: knowing short-cuts like right-click drag and drop, copying views to retain formatting and filters, and setting default formatting and aggregation on fields. But I think one of the biggest things is to know the data set well. Knowing the data set, the level of detail and what dimensions and measures are available allow you to know what’s possible, what’s easy, what calculations or filters are needed – and know that will help you move quickly.
Tristan: Repeat. Repeat. Repeat. And definitely use the Pause Auto Updates button! Every drag and drop issues a query and with nine sheets in my dashboard, I couldn’t afford to wait a few seconds after every move. So I hit the pause button and I knew exactly where to put all the dimensions and measures in rows, columns, filters, colors,… After placing all elements, I hit again the play button and just wait for one query. That was my game changer but there are many more things to gain seconds. It needs a complete article!
Tell us more about the day of the competition, how did you feel being on stage?
Jacob: The days and hours leading up to the competition were a combination of nervousness and excitement. Once I got up on stage the nervousness went away and I was way more comfortable then I expected, it was actually quite a thrill. I am confident that I will never feel nervous or overwhelmed by a presentation again!
Joshua: It’s incredible to step out on a stage like that with thousands of people watching you and cheering you on. I found it quite energizing and exciting. I felt confident with what I planned to do, but I think there’s always a level of nervous energy when you step onto a stage like that!
Tristan: I usually don’t sweat the stage. Lots of people noticed that I was quite zen about it. Truth is I wasn’t afraid about 20-minutes dashboard creation. I repeated a lot and I was confident about finishing it in 20 minutes. The speech part however… If it had been in French I would have probably enjoyed it much more! I spent the day before the competition in my room, repeating the speech. Again and again. A few minutes before being on stage, I was really nervous about that speech. And then Elissa Fink came and told me “Don’t be ashamed of your French accent, we loved it” and voilà, you know the rest!
— Jacob Olsufka (@j_olsufka) October 11, 2017
A little... pic.twitter.com/mflYiLrWDS
— Joshua Milligan (@VizPainter) October 10, 2017
Would you do something different now that the competition is over?
Jacob: Looking back I would have done more to prepare myself to be ready for anything (questions/comments) from the judges. As competitors we can use these questions as an opportunity to elaborate more on the decisions we made, and I would have been able to better respond to the specific feedback about color blindness. Afterwards I ran my viz through multiple color blindness simulators and was able to see that contrary to the feedback, colorblind people can see the distinction between the blue and orange lines.
Joshua: It had crossed my mind to use the animation capabilities of Tableau, but I had dismissed it fairly quickly. Seeing the audience reaction to Tristan and Jacob’s effective use of the feature in telling an engaging story makes me look back on my choice and wonder. But ultimately, no, I wouldn’t change anything.
Tristan: I came in Vegas Monday afternoon, after a 16 hours long trip. And left Thursday, just after lunch. I missed a lot of people and cool things happening during the TC. IronViz was probably a bit too much in my head. I should have allow me to spend more time enjoying being for the first time in United States with the best community!
Any advice for future competitors?
Jacob: The feeder contests are a great way to test your skills and push yourself to greatness. My advice would be to find a data set that you love working with. My best work comes when I am passionate and excited about a project, so find something that inspires you and run with it.
Joshua: Have fun and never stop learning! I never thought I’d win the feeder contest. I looked at it as an opportunity to engage with the community and grow in my data storytelling. The actual contest was a blast! My advice: push yourself, engage with others, and learn from them but never lose the excitement or joy that comes from creating something new and meaningful. And listen to the advice of your sous-vizzer!
Tristan: For the feeder, just do it. Even if you think it’s not good enough. Do it. And if you are not selected, ask for advice and start again. Worst case scenario, I just became better in Tableau! If you are selected for the final, enjoy it as much as you can. It’s an awesome event and like Curtis Harris told us a few second before the beginning, something you’ll never forget.
What are your best memories?
Jacob: My favorite part of the competition was hanging out with the crew all day. We all were anxious, but being together and getting to know one another was a lot of fun. We were able to meet up afterwards and continue the fun night at Data Night Out.
Joshua: Just hanging out with Tristan, Jacob, my sous-vizzer David, and everyone else involved in the competition. The nervous laughter and jokes and stories in the greenroom, being led in Tableau yoga by Jewel and moving along my Y-axis, being on stage, answering the judges questions – all of it combined makes for an experience I will never forget!
Tristan: Winning a competition is great, but you are always alone when you win. Even if there are hundreds of people saying congrats and wanting to take pictures with you, you live it alone. And for me the best moments are always moments that you can share. So being in the green room, all (ironviz contestant, sous vizzers and MCs) equally stressed, equally anxious and a bit lost, all sharing events in your life to try to think about something else.. That was my best memory. Second best was, without doubt, the Data Night Out and our little trip in Vegas with the great David Freifeld!